PaidQuiz vs. Conjured Memberships: An In-Depth Comparison

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. PaidQuiz vs. Conjured Memberships: At a Glance
3. Deep Dive Comparison
4. Which App Is Best For Which Merchant?
5. The Alternative: Unifying Commerce, Content, and Community Natively
6. Implementation Scenarios and Recommended Architectures
7. Practical Checklist for Choosing Between PaidQuiz, Conjured Memberships, and a Native Platform
8. Conclusion
9. FAQ

Introduction

Shopify merchants who want to sell digital products, run paywalled experiences, or build member communities face a choice between specialized apps that solve one problem well and platforms that try to do several things together. Picking the right tool affects revenue, customer experience, and how much time is spent on support and integrations.

Short answer: PaidQuiz is focused on selling interactive quizzes as standalone digital products and is simplest for merchants who need paywalled assessments or personality/skill tests. Conjured Memberships is a mature membership management tool built to handle recurring access, perks, and gated content at scale. Both have clear strengths, but neither fully addresses the friction of using multiple single-purpose tools outside of Shopify. For merchants seeking a native, all-in-one solution that bundles courses, gated content, communities, and commerce within Shopify, a platform like Tevello is positioned as a higher-value alternative.

This post compares PaidQuiz and Conjured Memberships feature-by-feature, pricing-by-pricing, and use-case-by-use-case to help merchants choose wisely. The comparison is impartial and outcome-focused: the aim is to identify which app is best for specific merchant needs and when a native, unified platform may be a better long-term strategy.

PaidQuiz vs. Conjured Memberships: At a Glance

Deep Dive Comparison

This section compares PaidQuiz and Conjured Memberships across the categories that matter most to merchants: features, pricing and value, integrations, customer experience, support, scalability, and migration.

Product Focus and Positioning

PaidQuiz: Narrow, Product-Led Focus

PaidQuiz is built around a single proposition: create interactive quizzes and sell them as digital products directly in a Shopify store. The core value is simplicity—merchants can create questions, set scoring, personalize results messaging, and embed an in-store portal where customers take the quiz and purchase access.

Strengths in positioning:

• Clear product-market fit for exam prep, assessments, and personality or skill testing.
• Straightforward product listing: a quiz is a digital item customers can buy like any other Shopify product.
• Free-to-install starter plan lowers the barrier to experiment.

Trade-offs:

• Small scope means merchants needing memberships, drip content, or full course structures may need additional apps.
• Limited social or community features. No built-in discussion forums or member messaging.

Conjured Memberships: Memberships as a Platform

Conjured Memberships is positioned as an end-to-end membership solution. It targets brands that want recurring access, member perks, exclusive pricing, and gated content at any volume. The product claims precise control and native Shopify checkout integration, plus a long list of supported integrations for email, fulfillment, and subscription services.

Strengths in positioning:

• Built to scale and handle high-volume membership programs.
• Flexible perks (discounts, free shipping, early access) and content gating.
• Known provider with 77 reviews and a 4.7 rating—signals reliability for merchants.

Trade-offs:

• While feature-rich for memberships, it is not a dedicated LMS or course platform; for multi-module courses with quizzes, certificates, and detailed learning paths, additional tools or workarounds may be required.
• Depending on a merchant’s current tech stack, configuring integrations (subscriptions, content delivery) will take planning.

Features: What Each App Can Do

PaidQuiz — Feature Snapshot

• Create sellable quizzes with customizable questions and scoring.
• Deliver quizzes inside an embedded in-store portal.
• Branded experience on the Starter plan; option to remove branding on Professional.
• Monetization tied directly to Shopify product purchase flows.

Practical implications:

• Quick to set up for straight quiz sales.
• Good for one-off monetization: a single exam, personality test, or certification test a customer pays to take.
• Lacks advanced membership primitives: no recurring billing, member perks, access tiers, drip content, or community features.

Conjured Memberships — Feature Snapshot

• Unlimited members in paid tiers; member management and segmentation.
• Offer perks such as member discounts, free shipping, and early access.
• Gate product pages and sections of the site for member-only visibility.
• Customizable member portal HTML & emails for on-brand experience.
• Integrates with native Shopify checkout and various email and fulfillment tools.
• Scales into enterprise with lower transaction fees at higher tiers.

Practical implications:

• Built for repeatable revenue models and loyalty programs.
• Handles both access control for digital content and perks tied to commerce.
• Requires workarounds or integration for course-like structures (progress tracking, lessons, certificates).

Content Delivery and Learning Tools

PaidQuiz

PaidQuiz excels at one format: quizzes. The tool is not positioned as a course or lesson manager. Its delivery model suits single-session, assessment-based products. There’s no native lesson sequencing, drip scheduling, or community discussion feed.

Use cases:

• Selling certification exams, timed tests, or single-experience assessments.
• Personality tests that produce paid personalized reports.

Not appropriate for:

• Multi-module courses, cohorts, or member communities requiring discussion centers, comments, or learning paths.

Conjured Memberships

Conjured allows access to gated content and “members-only” downloads, which makes it possible to host videos or files behind membership gates. It’s not a dedicated LMS with progress tracking, certificates, or quizzes built into lessons, though it supports delivering downloadable content and gated pages.

Use cases:

• Gating on-demand video libraries, PDF downloads, and exclusive product launches.
• Creating tiers of access and perks for subscribers.

Not appropriate for:

• Course experiences that require built-in assessments, graded quizzes, certificates, and learner dashboards without external tools.

Checkout, Native Integration, and Customer Experience

Checkout and Payment Flow

PaidQuiz sells quizzes as Shopify products, which keeps the purchase inside the store’s normal checkout flow. The embedded portal is designed to provide a seamless experience where the quiz is taken and access is purchased without moving customers off-site.

Conjured Memberships explicitly emphasizes native checkout integration and tight connection to customer accounts. Member entitlements and perks can be enforced by Shopify data (tags, customer metafields), allowing discounts and shipping rules to apply at checkout in a native way.

Implications:

• Both apps keep payments within Shopify, avoiding third-party checkouts that can complicate tracking and friction.
• Conjured’s proven, broader integration with checkout-level perks gives merchants more power to tie membership benefits to purchases without heavy engineering.

Customer Journey and Access

PaidQuiz provides a consumer flow where the user engages with a quiz and purchases access. It’s straightforward for single-transaction experiences.

Conjured’s membership flow supports recurring relationships—members sign up, receive ongoing perks and content, and the merchant can segment and communicate with members through integrated email and automation tools.

Implications:

• For one-off purchases, PaidQuiz provides a smoother product selling experience.
• For retention and LTV-focused programs, Conjured provides the infrastructure to create recurring contact and benefits.

Pricing and Value for Money

Pricing is often the deciding factor when merchants evaluate apps. Both apps offer free or low-cost entry points, but their value depends on merchant needs and the total cost of ownership when additional apps are required.

PaidQuiz Pricing

• Starter: Free to install — provides sellable quizzes, embedded quiz portal, branded experience.
• Professional: $100/month — sellable quizzes, embedded quiz portal, unbranded experience.

Value considerations:

• Low initial cost for testing the model (free starter).
• Professional tier becomes a fixed monthly cost for unbranded experiences; no public evidence of tiered usage-based pricing.
• If a merchant needs memberships, drip content, or course structures in addition to quizzes, those will require separate purchases or custom solutions, increasing the overall cost.

Conjured Memberships Pricing

• Free Development plan for partner/dev stores.
• Limited Special: $9.99/mo (limited-time/marketing plan).
• Starter: $19/mo — unlimited members & revenue, custom HTML & emails, member perks.
• Growth: $69/mo — lower transaction fees, better for scaling; enterprise pricing available.

Value considerations:

• Starter plan ($19/mo) offers broad membership functionality and unlimited members—good predictable pricing for scaling.
• Growth plan reduces transaction fees; cost-benefit depends on transaction volume.
• For merchants wanting to run true membership programs tied to commerce, Conjured delivers strong value for money versus building the same features via multiple apps.

Comparative note:

• PaidQuiz’s pricing suits merchants focused on single-product monetization of quizzes.
• Conjured’s pricing is structured for recurring revenue builders and typically offers more predictable value for membership-focused merchants.

Integrations and Extensibility

PaidQuiz

• Core functionality is self-contained: quiz creation and sale.
• Limited public integration information suggests fewer built-in connectors than Conjured.
• Merchants will likely need to rely on additional apps for email automation, subscriptions, or video hosting.

Conjured Memberships

• Lists direct integrations and compatibility with many Shopify-native workflows and third-party tools: Checkout, Customer accounts, Shopify Flow, Klaviyo, Sendgrid, Mailchimp, Churnbuster, CreditsYard, Sky Pilot, and subscription apps like Appstle or Seal.
• This ecosystem compatibility allows Conjured to fit into an existing stack with less custom work.

Practical outcome:

• Conjured provides more flexibility for merchants who already run email automation, subscriptions, and fulfillment workflows.
• PaidQuiz is lighter-weight; merchants should plan for complementary tools if they need broader functionality.

Reporting, Analytics, and Data Ownership

PaidQuiz

• Designed primarily for product sales; reporting centers on purchases of quizzes.
• No publicized advanced analytics for learner progress, cohort retention, or member LTV.

Conjured Memberships

• Focused on member metrics and offers tools to segment and manage the member base.
• Because it integrates with Shopify and common marketing tools, merchants can pull membership performance into their existing analytics stack (Klaviyo, Shopify reports, etc.)

Practical outcome:

• Conjured provides richer signal for lifetime value, churn, and membership performance when connected to analytics tools.
• PaidQuiz provides transaction-level data tied to quiz sales, but deeper membership and engagement metrics will be limited.

Support, Documentation, and Store Ratings

PaidQuiz

• According to the available data, PaidQuiz shows 0 reviews and a rating of 0 in the Shopify App Store. That can mean a new app with limited public feedback.
• Newer apps can innovate quickly, but merchants should consider the risk of limited real-world validation and support bandwidth.

Conjured Memberships

• 77 reviews with a 4.7 rating in the Shopify App Store signals a strong track record and merchant satisfaction.
• Conjured markets responsive support from the team that built the product alongside documentation and proven integration patterns.

Practical outcome:

• Conjured’s review volume and rating are strong indicators of reliability and active support.
• PaidQuiz may still be a solid, focused product, but the lack of reviews suggests merchants should request demos, test the free plan, and validate response times before committing.

Scalability, Performance, and Reliability

PaidQuiz

• Scales well for the single use-case of selling quizzes — minimal surface area means fewer points of failure.
• The main scalability question is how the quiz hosting and performance behave under high traffic; the app description indicates embedded in-store delivery but does not publish SLA details.

Conjured Memberships

• Built to handle high-volume membership programs and claims enterprise-grade support and lower transaction fees at scale.
• Conjured’s integrations with Shopify checkout and partners reduce the chances of friction as member numbers grow.

Practical outcome:

• For high membership volume, Conjured is explicitly built for scale.
• For straightforward quiz sales, PaidQuiz should suffice, but merchants must validate performance under peak load if expecting heavy traffic.

Security and Compliance

Both apps operate within Shopify, which provides baseline platform security. Important merchant considerations include:

• Ownership of customer data: both apps should respect Shopify’s data model; Conjured explicitly uses Shopify customer accounts and tags for entitlements.
• Payment handling: purchases are handled by Shopify checkout—no sensitive payment processing outside Shopify.
• Content access control: Conjured offers robust gating tied to Shopify accounts; PaidQuiz controls access to quizzes as purchased products.

Merchants should confirm data retention policies and export capabilities during evaluation.

Use Cases and Merchant Profiles

This section summarizes which merchants will likely choose each app.

Ideal PaidQuiz Merchant

• Sells assessments, certification tests, personality tests, or single-session paid quizzes.
• Wants a minimal setup: create a quiz, embed it in the store, and sell it.
• Needs a low-risk way to test a digital product without investing in a full course platform.

Why choose PaidQuiz:

• Simplicity and direct monetization of interactive quizzes.
• Free starter plan for proof-of-concept.

Potential limitations for this merchant:

• If the goal shifts to recurring revenue, cohort-based courses, or community building, additional tools will be required.

Ideal Conjured Memberships Merchant

• Wants a membership or loyalty program tied to ecommerce.
• Needs recurring revenue, member perks (discounts, shipping), or gated content.
• Plans to scale membership numbers and requires native checkout integration and marketing integrations (Klaviyo, Mailchimp).

Why choose Conjured:

• Mature feature set for memberships, sensible pricing for scaling, and strong app store reviews.
• Works well for brands thinking beyond single purchases to long-term engagement.

Potential limitations for this merchant:

• If the primary goal is a structured course platform with lessons, quizzes, certificates, and learning paths, Conjured may need to be combined with an LMS or course app.

Migration and Switching Costs

• PaidQuiz: Low friction to start and stop; quizzes are digital products—if merchant stops using the app, access control and content delivery methods may require alternative systems to keep content available.
• Conjured: Designed as a primary membership control layer. Migrating large membership bases to another provider will involve exporting member data, reassigning entitlements, and potentially reconfiguring checkout perks. However, Conjured's integration with native Shopify constructs (tags, metafields) simplifies migration relative to external third-party systems.

Merchants should factor in developer time, customer communication, and the potential re-issuance of access codes or new account flows.

Pros and Cons Summary

PaidQuiz — Pros

• Lightweight, focused on selling quizzes.
• Quick to set up; free starter plan.
• Embedded in-store experience keeps customers on site.

PaidQuiz — Cons

• Limited to quizzes; no membership primitives.
• No public track record of merchant reviews.
• Additional needs require other apps or custom work.

Conjured Memberships — Pros

• Mature membership feature set and strong app store rating (4.7 from 77 reviews).
• Native Shopify checkout and rich integrations.
• Predictable pricing for unlimited members and scalable tiers.

Conjured Memberships — Cons

• Not a full LMS—course-like features may need extra apps.
• Implementation complexity depends on desired member benefits and integrations.

Which App Is Best For Which Merchant?

• For brands that want to monetize single assessments, certifications, or interactive personality tests without building a course ecosystem, PaidQuiz is the simpler fit.
• For brands aiming to create recurring relationships, tie perks directly to purchases, and scale memberships, Conjured Memberships is the stronger choice.
• For merchants who want to combine courses, gated content, communities, and physical product bundles under one native Shopify roof, neither PaidQuiz nor Conjured is a complete single-point solution—this is where a unified native platform becomes valuable.

The Alternative: Unifying Commerce, Content, and Community Natively

Platform fragmentation is a real and costly problem for merchants. Using a separate course platform, a membership app, a quiz tool, plus email and subscription services creates multiple login points, inconsistent brand experiences, and extra work to connect customer identities. Every external redirect or third-party domain can lower conversion rates, increase support volume, and complicate reporting.

A native, all-in-one approach keeps customers "at home" on the merchant’s Shopify site, reduces friction at checkout, and unifies data for better insights. Tevello takes that approach by combining course delivery, memberships, quizzes, communities, and commerce within Shopify. The rationale is simple: when digital products, memberships, and physical goods are sold from the same store and governed by a single experience, average order values, retention, and lifetime value tend to improve.

Key benefits of a native alternative like Tevello:

• Unified checkout and customer accounts reduce friction and tech complexity.
• Bundling physical kits with digital courses increases AOV and LTV.
• Keeping customers on the merchant’s domain improves brand trust and conversion rates.
• Consolidated analytics and fewer integrations simplify growth planning.

Practical proof from merchants using a native approach:

• A brand consolidated courses from YouTube and physical products into one Shopify store and sold over 4,000 digital courses, generating over $112K in digital revenue and $116K in physical revenue by bundling them together.
• A photography brand used a native platform to upsell photographic courses and generated over €243,000 from 12,000+ course purchases, with more than half of sales coming from repeat purchasers.
• A large educational community migrated off a fragmented architecture and [migrated over 14,000 members to a native Shopify setup], adding 2,000+ new members and significantly reducing support tickets in the process (Charles Dowding case study).
• A brand that bundled physical DIY kits with on-demand courses achieved a 59%+ returning customer rate and saw returning customer AOV rise by 74%+ (Klum House case study).
• Another merchant replaced a "duct-taped" stack with a unified Shopify and native course setup and doubled store conversion rate by removing friction.
• A community that ran a short challenge kept all content and discussions on-store and converted a strong portion of participants into paying students because the experience felt cohesive and brand-owned (Madeit success story).

These examples illustrate a consistent outcome: merchants that centralize digital product and community commerce on Shopify see measurable gains in revenue, retention, and customer experience.

How Tevello Tackles Common Pain Points

• Customer Experience: Tevello uses Shopify’s native checkout and customer accounts to keep the purchase and learning journey consistent and on-brand. This reduces confusion and abandoned transactions.
• Bundling Digital and Physical: Because Tevello lives in Shopify, merchants can create bundles that include a physical product (e.g., a kit) and immediate access to a course—improving conversion and AOV.
• Scale and Support: Tevello offers an unlimited plan approach that makes pricing predictable for merchants who need many courses, members, or community spaces. Merchants can see feature-level details and choose a plan with a simple, all-in-one price for unlimited courses.
• Feature Parity and Beyond: Tevello includes course modules, drip content, certificates, bundles, quizzes, and community features—reducing the need for add-on apps. Merchants can explore all the key features for courses and communities.

Contextual comparison to PaidQuiz and Conjured Memberships:

• PaidQuiz focuses on selling quizzes, which is useful, but when adding memberships, lessons, and bundles, merchants typically add other tools. Tevello includes quizzes as part of a broader course and community toolkit.
• Conjured Memberships provides robust membership capabilities and native checkout perks, which align with Tevello’s membership features. Tevello adds course-specific primitives and native bundling with Shopify products in the same platform.

Seeing the Platform in Context

Merchants considering a move to a native platform can review multiple merchant stories to understand real outcomes. For example, see how merchants are earning six figures by using a native platform and the specific cases where bundling and consolidation created clear revenue lifts (Crochetmilie, fotopro, Charles Dowding). The Shopify App Store page for Tevello also includes social proof—read the 5-star reviews from fellow merchants.

Pricing Transparency and Predictability

Tevello’s pricing model aims to remove surprise costs by offering an unlimited plan that covers courses, members, and communities. Merchants who prefer straightforward monthly billing can review plans and pick one that fits growth expectations while avoiding per-member or per-course fees. For details about plan structure and to compare price points, merchants can view a simple, all-in-one price for unlimited courses.

When to Consider a Native Platform vs. Specialized Apps

Consider the following when making an architectural decision:

• If the primary product is a one-off paid quiz and the merchant does not plan to add courses, memberships, or bundled physical products in the near term, a focused app like PaidQuiz is likely a low-friction experiment.
• If the merchant is designing a loyalty program or membership-based commerce engine with perks and wants predictable pricing and scalability, Conjured Memberships is a strong solution.
• If the business model is to mix learning, content, community, and commerce—bundling physical and digital goods and optimizing for long-term retention—a native platform like Tevello often reduces the number of moving parts, improves conversion, and consolidates customer data for lifecycle marketing.

Merchants can explore all the key features for courses and communities and compare against their functional checklist to determine which path minimizes technical debt while maximizing customer lifetime value.

Implementation Scenarios and Recommended Architectures

This section outlines practical architectures and recommended app stacks for different merchant strategies.

Scenario: One-Off Paid Assessments

Architecture:

• Shopify store + PaidQuiz (for quiz creation and sale)
• Existing email provider for receipts and marketing

Why:

• Minimal cost and friction to launch.
• Keep the store lean and focused.

Caveat:

• If the assessment program is successful, expect additional investments to add repeat buyer flows or bundle content.

Scenario: Membership-Led Commerce with Perks and Gating

Architecture:

• Shopify store + Conjured Memberships + Klaviyo (or similar) for member segmentation and email campaigns + Sky Pilot or file-hosting if offering downloadable content.

Why:

• Conjured manages entitlements and integrates with checkout-level perks.
• Analytics and automation operate on customer segments built from membership data.

Caveat:

• For course-like learning experiences, add a course platform or plan to incorporate Tevello-like features.

Scenario: Unified Commerce + Courses + Community

Architecture:

• Shopify store + native all-in-one platform (Tevello) that handles courses, memberships, quizzes, communities, and bundles.

Why:

• Single platform reduces redirects, protects brand experience, and enables bundling physical and digital goods natively.
• Merchant examples show measurable growth in revenue and retention after consolidation (Crochetmilie, Klum House).

Caveat:

• Requires selecting a platform that aligns with specific learning features and scale expectations. Tevello offers a free trial so merchants can validate workflows.

Practical Checklist for Choosing Between PaidQuiz, Conjured Memberships, and a Native Platform

Use this checklist to decide which path suits the business goals.

• Primary objective is selling single, paid assessments? Consider PaidQuiz.
• Need recurring revenue, member perks, native checkout discounts, and scalable membership admin? Consider Conjured Memberships.
• Need to bundle physical and digital products, run courses with lessons and certificates, and build an on-site community to increase LTV? Consider a native platform like Tevello.

Merchants can further validate options by testing free tiers or demos, reviewing app store feedback, and measuring how many integrations would be needed to meet their full feature set. For review aggregation and community feedback on native course platforms, merchants can read the 5-star reviews from fellow merchants.

Conclusion

For merchants choosing between PaidQuiz and Conjured Memberships, the decision comes down to the business model:

• Choose PaidQuiz if the primary need is to sell single interactive quizzes or assessments quickly and with minimal setup.
• Choose Conjured Memberships if the goal is to build recurring revenue, administer perks and gated content at scale, and integrate memberships tightly with Shopify checkout and existing marketing tools.

If the objective is to unify courses, communities, and commerce under one native Shopify experience to increase LTV, reduce support overhead, and bundle physical and digital products seamlessly, a natively integrated platform is often the better long-term investment. Examples of merchants who consolidated their systems and saw measurable uplift include brands that generated over $112K by bundling courses with physical products, earned over €243K through course upsells, and migrated 14,000+ members to reduce support tickets and grow membership counts. See all the success stories for more detailed outcomes.

Start your 14-day free trial to unify your content and commerce today. (See pricing and plans)

FAQ

Q: How do PaidQuiz and Conjured Memberships differ in their core value? A: PaidQuiz is a specialized tool for creating and selling quizzes as digital products, focused on one-off transactions and assessment delivery. Conjured Memberships is a broader membership management platform that supports recurring access, member perks, gated content, and native Shopify checkout integration. Each targets a different merchant objective: immediate quiz monetization versus membership-driven revenue.

Q: Which app is better for running full course programs with lessons, progress, and certificates? A: Neither PaidQuiz nor Conjured Memberships is a full-featured LMS out of the box. PaidQuiz focuses on quizzes; Conjured focuses on membership access and perks. Merchants who want lessons, progress tracking, certificates, and integrated community features should consider a native course platform that includes those primitives. For merchants seeking those combined features natively within Shopify, see the feature set that unifies courses and communities.

Q: How does a native, all-in-one platform like Tevello compare to specialized or external apps? A: A native platform reduces fragmentation by keeping customers on the merchant’s site, leveraging Shopify checkout and customer accounts, and unifying analytics and access controls. That often raises conversion rates, reduces support tickets, and enables bundling of digital and physical products. Examples include merchants that sold 4,000+ digital courses and generated $112K+ by bundling and brands that generated over €243K by upselling course content.

Q: Where can merchants see pricing and reviews before committing? A: Merchants can review plan options and test the platform with a trial by checking a simple, all-in-one price for unlimited courses. To read merchant feedback and validation on the Shopify App Store, view the app listing and read the 5-star reviews from fellow merchants.