fbpx

How to Add Payment Options on Shopify: A Complete Guide for E-Commerce Success

Learn how to add payment options on Shopify to enhance customer experience and streamline transactions. Start optimizing your store today!

How to Add Payment Options on Shopify: A Complete Guide for E-Commerce Success

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Why Payment Setup Matters for Shopify Stores
  3. Payment Methods Available on Shopify
  4. Which Payment Method is Best for Shopify?
  5. Step-by-Step: How to Add Payment Method to Shopify Store
  6. How to Change Payment Method on Shopify Without Errors
  7. How to Remove Payment Method from Shopify Store
  8. Adding Manual Payment Methods to Shopify
  9. Common Issues When Changing Payment Methods on Shopify
  10. Advanced Tip: Use Multiple Payment Methods
  11. Control Payment Methods with PayRules
  12. FAQ: Shopify Payment Methods
  13. Conclusion

Introduction

In today's rapidly evolving e-commerce landscape, understanding how to add payment options on Shopify is more crucial than ever. Did you know that nearly 20% of online shoppers in the U.S. have abandoned their carts simply because the checkout process took too long? This statistic highlights a critical need for merchants to adapt their payment methods to meet customer expectations.

With the emergence of the knowledge economy, more Shopify merchants are looking to diversify their offerings beyond physical products, including online courses and digital products. As we at Tevello strive to empower Shopify merchants, we understand that the right payment options can significantly influence customer experience and retention—factors that directly affect revenue.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll take an in-depth look at how to successfully add and manage various payment options on your Shopify store to enhance customer satisfaction and streamline transactions. Whether you’re launching your first store or optimizing an existing one, we will walk you through multiple payment methods available today and provide best practices for leveraging them effectively.

Are you ready to transform your Shopify store’s payment setup? Let’s dive in!

Why Payment Setup Matters for Shopify Stores

The payment gateway serves as the bridge between your products and your revenue, making its setup a paramount aspect of any e-commerce store. Here’s why focusing on your payment options is essential:

Understanding these factors allows us as merchants to make informed decisions when adding or changing payment methods in our Shopify stores.

Payment Methods Available on Shopify

When it comes to Shopify’s payment options, your choices significantly vary based on the unique needs of your business. Here are the primary categories:

  1. Shopify Payments: The built-in payment processor that integrates natively with your online store. It offers low transaction fees and immediate payouts.
  2. PayPal: A widely recognized payment method that establishes customer trust and provides instant payment options.
  3. Stripe: A flexible payment gateway known for its international capabilities and advanced features for managing fraud.
  4. Manual Payments: Local payment options, such as cash on delivery (COD), bank transfers, or other offline methods.
  5. Digital Wallets: This includes Apple Pay, Google Pay, and other mobile payment solutions that cater to tech-savvy and mobile-first consumers.
  6. Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL): This payment method allows brands to offer financing options, which can boost average order values significantly.

Each payment method comes with its advantages and disadvantages that can swerve your decision depending on customer behavior, geographic considerations, and the nature of your products.

When to Use Which Payment Method?

Understanding when to utilize different payment methods can enhance your customer experience:

Which Payment Method is Best for Shopify?

Choosing the best payment method depends on various factors. Let’s analyze them:

  1. Shopify Payments: Offers a native solution with minimal transaction fees, fast payouts, and supports various digital wallets. Ideal for merchants seeking a straightforward setup.
  2. PayPal: Regarded for its merchant protection and speed, making it a reliable choice for both low and high-value transactions.
  3. Stripe: If your customer base is global or if you require extensive customizations, Stripe is likely the better fit, offering better tools for international payments and fraud detection.
  4. Manual Payments: Valuable for businesses focusing on local clientele or B2B transactions that may not use credit cards.

The ideal approach may often include a combination of these options to ensure you meet the diverse needs of your customers. As we aim to provide a seamless experience, it’s essential always to consider transaction fees, speed of transfers, and ease of use for customers.

Step-by-Step: How to Add Payment Method to Shopify Store

Now that we understand the importance of payment options, let’s explore how to add or modify them in your Shopify store effectively.

Step 1: Log in to Your Shopify Admin

Begin by logging into your Shopify admin dashboard. This is where all the magic begins!

Step 2: Access Payment Settings

Once you’re in, navigate to Settings > Payments. This page will serve as your control center for all payment methods.

Step 3: Go to the Additional Payment Method

Look for the "Accept payments" section. Click on the "Manage" or "Add payment method" option.

Step 4: Click Activate

From the list, choose the payment provider you wish to activate (e.g., PayPal, Stripe, etc.) and click the "Activate" button.

Step 5: Enter Account Credentials

You will be prompted to log in to your payment provider account or provide API keys to establish the connection between Shopify and your chosen payment method.

Step 6: Save and Test

After entering your details, don’t forget to click Save. It’s also good practice to place a test order to ensure everything works smoothly.

By following these steps, you’ll have successfully added a payment option to your Shopify store.

How to Change Payment Method on Shopify Without Errors

Switching payment methods can seem daunting, but you can execute it smoothly by adhering to a few best practices:

Step-by-Step Process

  1. Go to Settings > Payments.
  2. Click Manage under your current provider.
  3. Select Deactivate and confirm the action.
  4. Add a New Payment Method by following the above steps.
  5. Test the Checkout Process once the changes are complete.

Common Reasons for Changing Payment Methods

Perform your payment method switch during off-hours to minimize disruption to your customers.

How to Remove Payment Method from Shopify Store

If you find that a payment method no longer serves your needs, you can deactivate it:

Step-by-Step Process

  1. Head to Settings > Payments.
  2. Find the provider you wish to remove and select Manage.
  3. Click on Deactivate and confirm.

Reasons to Remove a Payment Method

Always remember that removing a payment option can change how customers interact with your store, so prioritize communication.

Adding Manual Payment Methods to Shopify

Manual payment options can be particularly useful in areas or scenarios where electronic payments are not viable. Here’s how you can add manual payment methods:

Step-by-Step Process

  1. Navigate to Settings > Payments.
  2. Scroll down to the Manual Payment Methods section.
  3. Click Add manual payment method.
  4. Choose your method (e.g., COD, bank transfer) and provide clear instructions for customers.
  5. Click Activate.

Manual payment methods can be instrumental in facilitating transactions during local deliveries or specific business setups.

Common Issues When Changing Payment Methods on Shopify

While the process is generally straightforward, you may encounter some issues:

Should any issues persist, don't hesitate to reach out for assistance—a quick chat with Shopify Support can often solve these hiccups!

Advanced Tip: Use Multiple Payment Methods

Offering multiple payment options not only enhances the customer experience but also boosts your conversion rates. Options such as combining Shopify Payments with PayPal can cater to a broader audience and instill confidence in potential buyers. This strategy also helps reduce cart abandonment, especially during peak shopping times when consumers want convenience.

Control Payment Methods with PayRules

For those looking to fine-tune their payment strategy further, utilizing a tool like PayRules can grant you added flexibility and security by:

This control offers not only better security but also enhances user experience significantly.

FAQ: Shopify Payment Methods

  1. Can I use multiple payment methods on Shopify? Yes! You can activate Shopify Payments along with PayPal, Stripe, and others to offer a variety of payment options.
  2. Which payment method is best for Shopify in 2025? Generally, Shopify Payments is the most recommended due to its seamless integration and low fees, although PayPal remains widely trusted.
  3. How do I change payment method Shopify safely? Deactivate your existing method before activating the new one. Remember to test the checkout process afterward.
  4. Can I remove payment methods I don’t use? Absolutely. Access Settings > Payments > Manage and then choose to Deactivate.
  5. How to add payment methods with custom options? For custom solutions, consider using third-party apps that can facilitate the integration of more advanced payment options.

Conclusion

Establishing the right payment methods in your Shopify store is fundamental to ensuring a positive shopping experience for your customers. From integrating popular options like credit cards and PayPal to enhancing customer confidence through secure transactions, every step you take brings you closer to improved sales and customer loyalty.

As you continually evaluate and refine your payment strategies, keep in mind that adjusting to customer needs is vital. The ability to change your payment methods and structures will empower you to create a frictionless checkout experience.

Now that you are equipped with the knowledge of how to add payment options on Shopify, let's transform the checkout experience for your customers. Start your 14-day free trial of Tevello today, and explore how you can further leverage your Shopify store for courses and communities while streamlining payments!


By, engaging the right payment methods and leveraging tools like Tevello, we can unlock new pathways to revenue and deepen connections with our customers. Your Shopify store is just a click away from heightened success!