fbpx
Shopify Guides October 14, 2025

How to Add More Payment Options on Shopify to Enhance Your E-Commerce Business

Learn how to add more payment options on Shopify to boost sales and reduce cart abandonment. Elevate your store's performance today!

How to Add More Payment Options on Shopify to Enhance Your E-Commerce Business Image

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. The Importance of Multiple Payment Options
  3. Types of Payment Methods to Consider
  4. Setting Up Multiple Payment Options on Shopify
  5. The Impact of Offering Diverse Payment Options
  6. Tevello’s Role in Enhancing Your E-Commerce Strategy
  7. Conclusion
  8. FAQ

Introduction

Did you know that nearly 20% of U.S. shoppers have abandoned purchases due to slow checkout processes? As merchants in the e-commerce world, we understand that payment flexibility is not just a nicety but a necessity. With consumers today seeking quick and convenient payment methods, knowing how to add more payment options on Shopify becomes an essential skill for Shopify store owners.

The rise of various payment methods, including mobile wallets, buy now, pay later options, and even cryptocurrencies, signifies a shift in consumer expectations. As we navigate the landscape of online shopping, it’s paramount for us to diversify our payment offerings. This not only enhances customer satisfaction but also fuels business growth by converting more browsers into buyers.

In this blog post, we will explore the comprehensive steps we can take to add more payment options on Shopify, focusing on the various payment methods available, how to set them up, and the potential impact on our sales. Additionally, we will highlight how Tevello’s all-in-one solution can help Shopify merchants like us seamlessly integrate these features into our stores.

Are you ready to elevate your Shopify store's payment options and, consequently, its performance? Let's dive in.

The Importance of Multiple Payment Options

Providing multiple payment options is essential for several reasons:

  1. Customer Preferences: Customers often have preferred methods of paying for goods, and offering a range of options can cater to diverse needs.
  2. Reduced Cart Abandonment: A complex or lengthy checkout process leads to abandoned carts. Streamlining payment can significantly reduce this.
  3. Increased Conversion Rates: Research shows that offering payment options like Shop Pay can boost conversions by as much as 50%.

These factors contribute to achieving our ultimate goal: creating a smoother shopping experience that encourages repeat business.

Types of Payment Methods to Consider

Understanding various payment methods will help us make informed decisions about what's best for our Shopify stores.

1. Credit and Debit Cards

As the most prevalent payment method, credit and debit cards are essential for any Shopify store. Major cards like Visa, Mastercard, and American Express are nearly universally accepted.

Advantages:

  • Widespread Acceptance: Most customers are familiar and comfortable using cards.
  • Higher Average Order Values (AOV): Customers tend to spend more when using credit cards.

Disadvantages:

  • Processing Fees: Merchants can incur fees of 1% to 3.5%, depending on the card provider.
  • Chargebacks: Fraudulent disputes can lead to financial losses.

2. Cash on Delivery (COD)

Especially prevalent in regions with low credit card penetration, COD allows customers to pay in cash upon delivery.

Advantages:

  • No Processing Fees: Merchants do not incur payment processing fees.
  • Instant Payment: Cash is accessible immediately upon delivery.

Disadvantages:

  • Logistical Challenges: Managing cash can be risky and impractical for online merchants.

3. Mobile Wallets

Payment solutions like Apple Pay, Google Pay, and others have gained traction due to their convenience.

Advantages:

  • Fast Transactions: Mobile wallets enable quick and efficient payments.
  • Security: These wallets often use advanced security protocols.

Disadvantages:

  • Equipment Upgrades: Accepting mobile wallet payments may require new hardware.
  • Transaction Limits: Limits can cap purchases, impacting larger sales.

4. Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL)

Popularized by companies like Affirm and Klarna, BNPL allows customers to split their payments into manageable installments.

Advantages:

  • Access for More Customers: Even those without good credit can access credit.
  • Higher Conversion Rates: Customers often spend more when able to finance.

Disadvantages:

  • Higher Fees for Merchants: Retailers often face fees of 2% to 8%.

5. Cryptocurrency

With growing interest in the digital currency space, accepting cryptocurrencies can provide a competitive edge.

Advantages:

  • Global Transactions: Cryptocurrencies can facilitate international sales without currency conversion fees.
  • Innovative Payment Method: Early adoption can attract tech-savvy customers.

Disadvantages:

  • Volatility: The value of cryptocurrencies can fluctuate wildly.
  • Limited User Base: Not all customers are comfortable using digital currencies.

6. Checks

Although less common, accepting checks can benefit businesses with established relationships or specific customer bases.

Advantages:

  • Flexibility in Payment Size: Customers can write checks for any amount.

Disadvantages:

  • Fraud Risk: Checks are susceptible to fraud, thus creating financial risks for merchants.

Setting Up Multiple Payment Options on Shopify

Now that we’re aware of various payment methods, let’s discuss the steps to integrate them into our Shopify store.

Step 1: Access Payment Settings

  • Log in to your Shopify admin panel.
  • Go to Settings and select Payments.

Step 2: Choose Your Payment Provider

Shopify offers native payment methods such as Shopify Payments, but it also allows integration with third-party gateways.

  • Shopify Payments: Simplifies the process, allowing us to accept credit/debit cards, Apple Pay, and more without setting up a third-party provider.
  • External Payment Providers: Platforms such as PayPal, Authorize.Net, and more have their setup requirements.

Step 3: Configure Payment Methods

Within the payments settings, we can select our desired payment methods:

  • For Shopify Payments, we simply need to enable it and configure our account.
  • For mobile wallets, we need to enable those options through integrations and follow third-party instructions provided by the services we choose.

Step 4: Add Buy Now, Pay Later Options

To add BNPL options, we can enable services through integrations like Shop Pay Installments:

  1. Enable Shopify Payments to access BNPL features.
  2. Follow prompts to set up conditions and terms for payment plans.

Step 5: Set Up Cryptocurrency Payment Acceptance

Implementing cryptocurrencies may require additional steps:

  1. Choose a payment processor specializing in crypto, like Coinbase Commerce.
  2. Sign up for an account and integrate it with Shopify.

Step 6: Review and Test

Before going live, it's important to test every payment option to ensure functionality and a seamless customer experience.

The Impact of Offering Diverse Payment Options

Diverse payment options are not just about keeping up with trends; they have tangible effects on our business.

  1. Improved Customer Experience: Offering multiple payment options ensures our customers can choose what’s convenient for them.
  2. Enhanced Customer Loyalty: Reduced friction in the checkout process increases the likelihood of repeat business.
  3. Augmented Revenue: Incorporating features like BNPL often leads to increased transaction sizes, boosting the overall revenue.

Tevello’s Role in Enhancing Your E-Commerce Strategy

At Tevello, we believe in empowering Shopify merchants by providing an all-in-one solution that seamlessly integrates with the Shopify ecosystem. By enabling you to create and manage online courses, build vibrant communities, and add multiple payment options, we help you unlock new revenue streams while also strengthening connections with your audience.

How Tevello Facilitates Payment Integration

  • Streamlined Setup: Our platform simplifies the integration process, ensuring merchants can add multiple payment options without technical headaches.
  • User-Friendly Interface: We pride ourselves on a user-friendly experience that allows merchants to focus on selling.
  • Robust Features: With our comprehensive features, you can offer courses and digital products while efficiently managing payment options.

Ready to enhance your Shopify store? Start your 14-day free trial of Tevello today!

Conclusion

Adding more payment options on Shopify is a crucial step towards enhancing our e-commerce business. By providing diverse payment methods, we can improve customer experiences, reduce cart abandonment rates, and ultimately increase revenue.

Incorporating Tevello’s capabilities into our Shopify platform allows us to harness the benefits of an integrated solution that brings together course creation, community building, and diverse payment options.

Let’s take our Shopify store to new heights. Start your free trial with Tevello today and unlock the potential of your online business!

FAQ

How do multiple payment options help in reducing cart abandonment?

Providing various payment methods allows customers to choose their preferred checkout process. If they can’t find a method that suits their needs, they are more likely to abandon their carts. Having multiple options reduces friction and increases the likelihood of completing the transaction.

Are there any fees associated with adding new payment options?

Most payment methods have associated fees, including transaction fees varying from 1% to 8%. It's essential to review the terms of each payment provider chosen to understand their fee structures.

Can I add cryptocurrency payment options to my Shopify store?

Yes, by using a third-party payment processor that accommodates cryptocurrency transactions, you can add this payment option. Investments in setup verification processes are required, as volatility affects these transactions.

How does Tevello support me in optimizing my payment methods?

Tevello provides a user-friendly platform that simplifies the integration of various payment methods into your Shopify store. Our robust features and supportive community can help you manage and optimize your payment setup efficiently.


Whether you're a seasoned e-commerce pro or just starting, diversifying your payment options is paramount to your store's success. We hope this detailed guide empowers you to implement these strategies confidently and transform your Shopify experience.

Are you ready to get started? Install the all-in-one course platform for Shopify now!

Share blog on:

Start your free trial today

Add courses and communities to your Shopify store in minutes.

Start free Trial
Background Image
Start your free trial today
Add courses and communities to your Shopify store in minutes.
Start free Trial
Background Image
See Tevello in Action
Discover how easy it is to launch and sell your online courses directly on Shopify.
Book a demo