fbpx
Shopify Guides October 14, 2025

What Payment Provider Should I Use for Shopify? A Comprehensive Guide

Unsure about what payment provider should I use for Shopify? Discover the best options and boost your e-commerce success today!

What Payment Provider Should I Use for Shopify? A Comprehensive Guide Image

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Understanding Payment Gateways and Processors
  3. The Importance of Selecting the Right Payment Provider
  4. Top Payment Providers for Shopify
  5. Factors to Consider When Choosing a Payment Provider
  6. Tevello: Your Comprehensive Solution for Selling Online Courses and Digital Products
  7. FAQ

Introduction

Imagine trying to run your e-commerce store without the ability to process digital payments. Would you venture into the cashless economy? You might be surprised to know that, as of 2023, cash transactions account for only 14% of all sales in the United States. With consumers rapidly shifting toward digital transactions—whether through credit cards, mobile wallets, or Buy Now, Pay Later options—understanding which payment provider to use for Shopify is essential for your business's success.

Choosing the right payment gateway can be the linchpin of your e-commerce strategy. It not only affects your bottom line—due to transaction fees—but also influences customer experience, sales conversion rates, and ultimately, customer loyalty. For Shopify merchants looking for an all-in-one solution to manage payments along with building vibrant online communities and selling digital products, Tevello empowers your business by providing a seamless integration of these essential services directly within your Shopify store.

In this blog post, we aim to equip you with in-depth knowledge to make an informed decision about which payment provider is best suited for your Shopify store. We'll cover everything from understanding payment gateways, analyzing various providers, and discussing unique use cases tailored to your business model.

So, as we dive in, we want you to consider: What are your specific needs, and how can Tevello help you navigate the complexities of e-commerce payment processing? We hope to show you that selecting a payment provider is not just a mere choice—it’s a strategic decision that can unlock new revenue streams and reinforce meaningful connections with your audience.

Understanding Payment Gateways and Processors

Before we zero in on the best payment providers for Shopify, we need a firm grasp of the concepts of payment gateways and payment processors.

What is a Payment Gateway?

A payment gateway acts as a digital bridge that securely collects a customer’s payment information—such as credit card numbers—during online transactions. It encrypts this data and enables the transaction approval process by communicating with both the customer’s bank and your merchant account.

  • Customer Input: When a customer initiates payment, they enter their details directly into the payment gateway.
  • Data Encryption: The payment gateway encrypts sensitive information to prevent unauthorized access.
  • Authorization: After validation, the gateway sends the transaction for authorization from the payment processor.

This complex interaction allows your store to accept cashless payments effortlessly.

What is a Payment Processor?

While the payment gateway is the front line that captures customer data, the payment processor manages the underlying transaction data. The payment processor verifies the customer’s information and facilitates the transfer of funds from the customer's bank to the merchant's bank account.

Key Functions of a Payment Processor:

  • Verifies the customer’s credit/debit card details.
  • Interacts with the issuing bank for authorization.
  • Transfers funds to the merchant’s bank account after approval.

Knowing how both payment gateways and processors function is crucial as it helps to understand the nuances of selecting the best payment provider for your Shopify store.

The Importance of Selecting the Right Payment Provider

With various options available to you, choosing a payment provider may seem overwhelming. Here are some key considerations that highlight the importance of making an informed choice.

Customer Experience

A smooth payment process enhances customer satisfaction and improves conversion rates. If your payment gateway is complex or doesn't offer popular payment options, customers may abandon their carts—leading to lost sales.

  • User-Friendly Interfaces: Gateways should provide an intuitive way for customers to input their payment information.
  • Multiple Payment Options: Support for a diverse range of payment methods, such as credit cards, e-wallets, and Buy Now Pay Later services, makes it easier for customers to purchase without friction.

Security and Compliance

In today's digital landscape, security must be a top priority. Payment gateways must adhere to strict compliance regulations like PCI DSS (Payment Card Industry Data Security Standards) to protect customer data.

  • Fraud Detection Tools: Look for providers that offer robust fraud prevention features.

Fees and Transaction Costs

Fees can significantly impact your profit margins. They usually fall into three categories:

  1. Transaction Fees: Typically a percentage + a flat fee per transaction.
  2. Monthly Fees: Some providers charge a subscription fee.
  3. Chargeback Fees: Be aware of potential fees incurred from processing disputed transactions.

Understanding these fees can help clarify the total cost of doing business and allow for effective financial planning.

Integration and Support

Opt for a payment provider that offers easy integration with your Shopify store. This allows for seamless management of payments without needing an external platform. Additionally, 24/7 customer support can significantly reduce stress during issues related to payments.


Top Payment Providers for Shopify

Now that we understand the fundamental concepts and importance of payment gateways, let's explore specific options available for Shopify merchants.

1. Shopify Payments

Overview: Shopify Payments is Shopify's native solution and should be the first choice for all Shopify merchants.

Why Choose It?

  • No additional monthly fees and lower transaction rates.
  • Built-in Features: Includes multi-channel selling support (Facebook, Instagram, TikTok).
  • International Payments: Supports various currencies and payment options like Shop Pay for faster checkout.

Transaction Fees:

  • Basic Plan: 2.9% + 30¢ for online transactions.
  • Advanced Plan: 2.5% + 30¢.

For a full overview of the features and how to get started with Shopify Payments, you can explore more here.

2. Stripe

Overview: Stripe is ideal for businesses that want a high volume of transactions or operate internationally.

Why Choose It?

  • Offers extensive customization for handling various payment methods.
  • Excellent for subscription services with features tailored for recurring billing.
  • Supports a wide range of currencies.

Transaction Fees: 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction, with additional fees for foreign currencies.

Many Shopify merchants find that integrating Stripe into their checkout process makes sense because of its engagement with global markets.

3. PayPal

Overview: PayPal is one of the most recognized names in online payment processing.

Why Choose It?

  • Extensive reach across 200 countries and support for 25 currencies.
  • Provides a sense of security for customers unfamiliar with your site.
  • Features like One Touch streamline the checkout process.

Transaction Fees: Varies from 2.59% to 3.49% based on the payment method.

The widespread acceptance of PayPal amongst consumers means it’s advisable to include this option in your payment suite.

4. Authorize.Net

Overview: A well-known name in the online payment processor space, Authorize.Net is user-friendly and offers various features.

Why Choose It?

  • Excellent for businesses that want to accept multiple payment methods.
  • Integrated fraud prevention tools to minimize risks.
  • Reliable customer support with 24/7 access.

Transaction Fees: $25 monthly and 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction.

For those merchants focused on robust customer support and detailed features, Authorize.Net is a compelling choice.

5. Square

Overview: Square offers a powerful payment solution particularly suited for small to mid-sized businesses.

Why Choose It?

  • Nested within a robust POS ecosystem, making it ideal for retail.
  • Transparent pricing structures and no monthly fees.

Transaction Fees: Approximately 2.6% + 10¢ per transaction.

Square’s integrations with Shopify make it an attractive option for merchants who also have physical stores.


Factors to Consider When Choosing a Payment Provider

With various payment providers to choose from, we need to discuss some critical factors that should guide your decision-making process.

1. Business Model Compatibility

Assess which payment provider aligns best with your business model. For instance, subscription services benefit more from providers like Stripe, while retail operations might thrive with Square.

2. Payment Methods

Analyze the needs of your target audience. If your customers frequently use digital wallets or buy now, pay later options, ensure your selected gateway supports these methods.

3. Fees and Costs

Be mindful of the fees associated with each payment provider. Calculate total charges to determine which gateway offers the best value based on your transaction volume and complexity.

4. Customer Support

You may encounter unforeseen challenges during your payment processing journey. Therefore, having reliable customer support is critical. Opt for providers who offer 24/7 assistance and have a strong reputation for responsiveness.

Tevello: Your Comprehensive Solution for Selling Online Courses and Digital Products

While selecting a payment provider is crucial, we at Tevello understand that it is just part of a wider strategy to build and grow your Shopify store. As an all-in-one platform, we enable merchants to create, manage, and sell online courses and digital products directly integrated with robust community-building features—all without needing to manage multiple external platforms.

Do you want to start a thriving online community and offer rich educational content? Here’s how Tevello can help:

  • Community Building: Engage with your audience through integrated features, promoting interaction and boosting customer loyalty.
  • Easy Course Creation: Our intuitive tools enable merchants to design and deliver courses seamlessly, adding valuable revenue streams to your business.
  • All-In-One Solution: Make the most of your Shopify ecosystem by managing everything from payments to products without the headaches associated with multiple providers.

Start Your Tevello Free Trial Today!

Don't leave your business opportunity opportunities on the table. We invite you to explore how Tevello can support your e-commerce journey. Ready to build your course? Start your 14-day free trial of Tevello today by clicking here.

FAQ

1. Can I use multiple payment providers on Shopify?

Yes, Shopify allows merchants to use multiple payment providers to accommodate various customer preferences. However, ensure that the integration is seamless and does not confuse shoppers at checkout.

2. How do I set up my payment provider?

To set up your payment provider, navigate to “Settings” in your Shopify admin panel, click on “Payments,” and follow the prompts to configure your chosen provider.

3. Are there transaction limits with these providers?

Most payment providers have transaction limits, especially for new accounts. However, they often increase limits after establishing a history of secure transactions.

4. Is it possible to switch payment providers once I start using one?

Yes, Shopify allows you to change your payment provider anytime. Ensure a smooth transition to avoid disruptions in payment processing.


As we conclude this exploration of choosing a payment provider for your Shopify store, remember that each option offers unique benefits tailored to different business models. As merchants, we have the opportunity to enhance our customers' shopping experiences while opening new revenue streams.

At Tevello, we believe in empowering you to achieve your business goals—our robust features, user-friendly interface, and transparent pricing will help you build the online store of your dreams.

Start your free trial today and see the benefits for yourself! Click here to get started with Tevello.

Share blog on:

Start your free trial today

Add courses and communities to your Shopify store in minutes.

Start free Trial
Background Image
Start your free trial today
Add courses and communities to your Shopify store in minutes.
Start free Trial
Background Image
See Tevello in Action
Discover how easy it is to launch and sell your online courses directly on Shopify.
Book a demo