fbpx
Shopify Guides October 14, 2025

How to Email Non-Subscribers on Shopify: A Complete Guide for Merchants

Learn how to email non subscribers on Shopify effectively. Unlock strategies for engagement and boost your store's revenue today!

How to Email Non-Subscribers on Shopify: A Complete Guide for Merchants Image

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Understanding Non-Subscribers
  3. Legal Considerations When Emailing Non-Subscribers
  4. Building an Effective Email Strategy for Non-Subscribers
  5. Utilizing Analytics to Measure Success
  6. Overcoming Common Challenges
  7. Success Stories: Transforming Audiences into Loyal Customers
  8. Emphasizing Brand Storytelling in Emails
  9. Conclusion
  10. FAQ Section

Introduction

Did you know that over 70% of online shoppers abandon their carts before completing a purchase? This statistic reveals a glaring opportunity for Shopify merchants to tap into a largely overlooked audience—non-subscribers. As the creator economy shifts towards diversifying revenue streams, understanding how to effectively engage these potential customers can make all the difference.

In the contemporary landscape of e-commerce, knowing how to nurture relationships beyond initial glimpses is critical, especially with the increasing competition. While many merchants focus on their existing subscribers, we at Tevello believe that reaching out to non-subscribers can significantly enhance customer retention, brand loyalty, and ultimately, revenue growth.

In this blog post, we will guide you through the strategies and best practices for emailing non-subscribers effectively on Shopify. We’ll explore the nuances of building relationships via email marketing, leveraging Tevello’s all-in-one platform, and why creating online courses can deepen connections with your audience. Are you ready to enhance your Shopify store’s reach and revenue potential? Let’s dive in and unlock these strategies together!

Understanding Non-Subscribers

Before we explore how to email non-subscribers effectively, let’s clarify who they are within the context of your Shopify store.

What Defines Non-Subscribers?

Non-subscribers are potential customers who have visited your store but haven’t signed up for your email list. They may have browsed through your products, added items to their cart, or even engaged with your social media but chose not to commit their contact details for future communications.

Why Target Non-Subscribers?

  1. Market Size: This demographic often represents a substantial portion of your total traffic. Ignoring them means you’re missing out on a significant audience ripe for conversion.
  2. Engagement Potential: Non-subscribers have shown interest in your brand. By initiating contact, you can gently guide them towards making a purchase while building trust.
  3. Feedback Loop: Engaging non-subscribers provides insights into customer preferences, allowing you to improve your offerings and marketing strategies.

Legal Considerations When Emailing Non-Subscribers

Before we dive into strategies, it’s essential to understand the legal landscape surrounding email marketing.

CAN-SPAM and GDPR Compliance

When approaching non-subscribers, compliance with regulations like the CAN-SPAM Act in the U.S. and GDPR in Europe is paramount. Here are some key points to consider:

  • Explicit Consent: Always obtain explicit consent before sending marketing emails. Consider adding a checkbox during the checkout process or on your site to collect opt-ins.
  • Clear Unsubscribe Options: Ensure every email includes a clear and straightforward unsubscribe option.
  • Accurate Information: Your emails should include your business’s physical address and identity.

By staying compliant, we maintain a trustworthy reputation while reaching a broader audience.

Building an Effective Email Strategy for Non-Subscribers

Creating an outreach strategy for non-subscribers involves several key steps that we will focus on. By using Tevello’s features, we can simplify and enhance this process.

Develop Eye-Catching Campaigns

At Tevello, we know that the first step is developing engaging and visually appealing email campaigns that capture attention. Here’s how:

  • Personalization: Use tools that allow you to segment your non-subscriber audience based on behavior. Personalizing emails can increase engagement rates significantly.
  • Compelling Content: Create valuable content such as tutorials or tips related to your offerings. For example, if you sell fitness equipment, you could include a “30-Day Fitness Challenge” guide that incorporates your products.
  • Strong Call-to-Action (CTA): Every email should have a clear CTA that pushes the reader to take action—be it visiting your site, checking out a course, or signing up for a newsletter.

Ready to build your course? Get started with Tevello and explore our robust email marketing features that enhance your outreach. Start your 14-day free trial of Tevello today.

Integrate Online Courses and Communities

Emphasizing Value: Incorporating online courses can significantly enhance your email strategy. Not only do courses represent a new revenue stream, but they also offer valuable content that non-subscribers may appreciate.

Imagine a Shopify merchant specializing in beauty products sending an email to non-subscribers with free access to a course titled “Skincare Essentials 101.” This approach not only showcases the products but also builds trust and authority in the space.

Community Engagement: Encouraging non-subscribers to join a community can lead to meaningful connections. Foster relationships by sending out invites to webinars, discussion forums, or support groups centered around your products.

Explore our powerful, all-in-one feature set for community engagement to connect deeply with your audience and keep them engaged. Explore our powerful, all-in-one feature set for course creation, communities, and digital products.

Timing and Frequency

Finding the right timing for your emails is essential:

  • Optimal Timing: Research shows that emails sent on weekdays during mid-morning garner higher open rates. However, consider testing different times to see what resonates with your audience.
  • Frequency Control: Avoid overwhelming your audience. A thoughtfully crafted monthly email or bi-weekly outreach can keep potential customers engaged without feeling spammed.

Utilizing Analytics to Measure Success

Tracking the performance of your email campaigns is crucial.

Key Metrics to Monitor

As merchants, we must analyze these metrics to refine our strategy over time:

  • Open Rates: Indicates how compelling your subject lines are.
  • Click-Through Rates (CTR): Shows how many recipients clicked on your links, providing insight into content efficacy.
  • Conversion Rates: Reflects the percentage of non-subscribers who made purchases or took action after clicking through your email.

Using an analytics dashboard will help streamline this process, allowing data-driven decision-making.

Overcoming Common Challenges

Even with a solid strategy, you may encounter challenges when emailing non-subscribers. Here’s how to navigate these obstacles:

Low Engagement Rates

  • A/B Testing: Test different subject lines, content formats, and layouts to see what resonates best with your audience needs.
  • Feedback Collection: Ask non-subscribers why they opted out or didn’t engage with your emails. Learn and adapt accordingly.

Email Deliverability Issues

  • Maintain a Clean List: Regularly update your mailing list to ensure you’re not emailing dormant or inactive accounts.
  • Authenticate Your Domain: Consider methods like SPF and DKIM authentication methods to increase trust and improve deliverability rates.

Success Stories: Transforming Audiences into Loyal Customers

Sharing success stories can help inspire our approach to outreach. Consider a hypothetical case of a Shopify merchant that uses Tevello:

Case Study: Crafting Connections

Imagine a merchant selling hobby supplies who decided to create an online course titled “Crafting Magic: Basics for Beginners.” She used email marketing to promote free trials of this course to non-subscribers, highlighting exclusive content and live webinars.

As a result, she saw a significant increase in course sign-ups and later transformed many of these participants into loyal subscribers and customers. This not only diversified her income but also strengthened her community.

Emphasizing Brand Storytelling in Emails

Incorporating storytelling into our email marketing can be a differentiator.

Why Stories Matter

People connect with stories—especially when they can identify with them. Share:

  • Your Journey: Explain your brand’s mission and the value it provides to customers.
  • Customer Experiences: Showcase testimonials or narratives from satisfied customers that demonstrate the impact of your products.

Each email becomes more than a sales pitch; it fosters connection.

Conclusion

As we’ve explored in this guide, effectively reaching out to non-subscribers can open new avenues for engagement and sales in your Shopify store. By understanding your audience, crafting compelling content, maintaining compliance, and utilizing analytics, we can transform potential shoppers into loyal customers.

At Tevello, we prioritize enabling Shopify merchants to harness these tools, empowering them to create and manage vibrant communities centered around quality content.

Start your 14-day free trial of Tevello today and see how we can help you unlock the full potential of your e-commerce store!

FAQ Section

What are the best practices for emailing non-subscribers?

Focus on obtaining consent, personalizing content, utilizing compelling CTAs, and maintaining compliance with legal regulations.

How can I increase engagement rates for my emails?

Consider A/B testing subject lines, using personalized content, and ensuring the timing and frequency align with recipient preferences.

What content should I include in emails for non-subscribers?

Incorporate valuable content such as tips, tutorials, and promotional offers. Highlight your unique courses and community-building opportunities.

How can I measure the success of my email campaigns?

Monitor key metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates to assess the impact and refine your strategy.

By following these strategies and insights, we can enhance our outreach efforts to non-subscribers and create relationships that lead to sustained revenue growth for our Shopify stores.

Share blog on:

Start your free trial today

Add courses and communities to your Shopify store in minutes.

Start free Trial
Background Image
Start your free trial today
Add courses and communities to your Shopify store in minutes.
Start free Trial
Background Image
See Tevello in Action
Discover how easy it is to launch and sell your online courses directly on Shopify.
Book a demo